52 Comments
User's avatar
Bernard Hickey's avatar

Beautifully, painfully and accurately said.

Mark Carnegie's avatar

It really is

Tim's avatar

Excellent stuff Andrew. Echoed in every call for a homeless person to "pull themselves up by their bootstraps", every voter who thinks "tough on crime" makes them safer, and every politician who believes healthcare and education need to just "do more with what they already have" - convenient fantasy.

Dr Andrew Dickson's avatar

And every teacher who brings bread and jam to school to feed their hungry students… the list goes on and on.

C Logan's avatar

No thank you. Fiscal puritanism can disappear along with the "affirmation-reciting" dear leader of condescending sadists. Thank you, Dr Dickson, for your honest expose of our strange New Zealand penchant to continue imposing ever-constrained conditions on innocent, hardworking New Zealanders as though they're somehow causing New Zealand's poor "productivity. No more. Let's reclaim our beautiful land before it's too late!

Dr Andrew Dickson's avatar

Beautifully said!

Mark Behnke's avatar

Witnessing the sadism of this current Finance Minister has been one of the saddest experiences I have had watching humans. And humans have shown me many…

The Rebel Economist's avatar

Blimmin good piece, Andrew. The lament-and-wire framing is the sharpest thing I've read on why the productivity story never dies. We fell in love with the deprivation and dressed it up as character.

The causality inversion is the part every economist skips. Productivity isn't a trait workers have or lack. It's what they're handed to work with, and we've spent forty years refusing to hand them anything. Cheap labour and suppressed demand, so the rational firm hires another cheap worker instead of buying the machine. Then we act mystified by the output-per-hour number we engineered.

And the NZ detail is right. We wrote the Reserve Bank Act in 1989, the first inflation target anywhere. We built the surplus liturgy and we still kneel at it hardest. The money was always there. We are the money. That's the whole thing, and you've tied it to the NZ context better than anyone.

Dr Andrew Dickson's avatar

Perfectly said!!

solardb's avatar

I think the last3 years have shown you can't rely on cuts to grow the economy. You need to have some investment to facilitate growth, and some slack to allow efficiency to work. Willis's single focus on debt reduction has done immense damage.

DavidM's avatar

... and Labour just doubled down on it today.

Annie's avatar

This is what concerns me most, people can change, we are starting to feel it now. Its being seen in some parts of the world manifesting itself into extreme right wing governments.

The question is, with the tools that we currently have to change our trajectory (voting) how do we fundamentally do the with the choices we have? Let's be real Labour and National are the same, just wearing different colour's with one side better at communicating with a sense of empathy. Our latest choice is e,a try the same, being clear they will work with, which a lot of kiwis (including me) has seen this as supporting the status quo.

Id love to understand how we now get out of this.

Annie's avatar

Fat fingers on my phone, e,a is actually TOP.

Russ Sewell's avatar

Great piece Andrew.

Under investment in plant and people is endemic, as is the mantra that shareholders must have dividends.

Also the cost of living crisis could be reframed as a low wage crisis.

This cruel government has no interest in raising either production or wages just punching down on workers and beneficiaries.

Tess Porter's avatar

Reframing the cost of living crisis as the low wage crisis is brilliant. I’m stealing it, please and thank you!

Simon Rutherford's avatar

And locking people up!

Dave  Cameron's avatar

Outstanding. Again. The whole essay builds to a wonderful crescendo in the last few paragraphs.

Really liked “Productivity is overwhelmingly a function of what workers are given to work with” and we’ve all seen that applied when workers are given power prices artificially elevated by a perverse pricing structure to appease Governments who must have the dividends of power companies to help “balance a budget”

I’m just imagining what it would be like having a government that killed the shibboleths and applied the remedy of this paper!

Joanna Tennent's avatar

Great writing and insightful analysis.

David Udy's avatar

Ditto Bernard's comments Andrew. Love the framing of the beautiful question 🤔

Gaylene Middleton's avatar

I don't have the skills of others. Your analysis is breathtaking and gives satiation.

TheOtherManOnTheClaphamOmnibus's avatar

One thing I have become very aware of in NZ is the speed with which commentators are quick to blame the referee. The All Blacks can’t just lose to a better team but it was due to a poor referee and so on. The same applies to the news media that seems incapable of accurately reporting stories which paint the country in a less than favourable light as the writer describes regarding the recent productivity figures. Time for change. Time to invest in something other than houses. Time for Nicola Willis to stop screaming that there is no money unless, of course, you are a landlord.

Fred's avatar

I think this the best I’ve read from you — and that’s a high bar!!

Dr Andrew Dickson's avatar

That’s lovely, thanks Fred :-)

Bill Kaye-Blake's avatar

Great discussion, Andrew. I would add two things. First, we do actually know how to be productive. If you look at the agricultural sector, you can see that it has good labour productivity. The reason is that we have put public money into research, turned the research into practices, and paid for the assets to do them well. Second, the number 8 wire is about plucky individuals while the poor productivity is about labour generally. The productivity lament has some flavour of the horror of the masses about it.

Meredith Osmond's avatar

Massive thanks Andrew. Loved the read and now full of deep thoughts about what next - more of the same or substantive change? Actually, I know the answer and it makes me very sad. Let’s circulate this widely and get the conversation going in another direction.

Kerry's avatar

Sheesh...

Geoff Bertram's avatar

Alas, precisely true. But lacking an origin story: New Zealand was not always thus. There is much to be learnt from scrutiny of the economic history of the four decades following the Second World War.

Chris Harris's avatar

The four decades that are the principal target of our many vicarious masochists, such as Kenneth Cumberland (whom I quote in a more recent comment) and for that matter Michael Bassett, who also harked back to the good old days of the 1930s in his 'Politics versus the Economy, 1940-1975,' viz:

"Ministers soon found that it took more than symbolic gestures to quell a generation of rising expectations. . . . The politics of rising expectations were getting completely out of hand. . . . The point to remember is that once the electorate had the taste of what could be achieved by a big spending government, it never let its politicians forget. . . . The problem was that believers in the Santa Claus state were not ready to forgo any of the presents they believed they were entitled to. Since the 1930s the voters had paid little heed to any economic difficulties facing the country; they always demanded action on promises."

And so on, yada yada.